David Bloom & Cliff Colnot play a ‘Shadow of a Soul’

David Bloom is a composer with a painter’s eye and Bill Colnot an arranger steeped in classical harmonies but with an international outlook. As Bloom explains,

over the last fifty years, I have met a few people who had an unusual level of spirituality, imagination, hipness, heart and individuality. Each one radiated an aura that was impossible to ignore. These people had what I have always called a Shadow of a Soul.

The album opens with ‘Mischievous Mark Colby’, written for a student of Blooms who had died the previous year. There is a melancholia about this tune, perhaps unsurprisingly, and a well-tempered sax solo from Dave Liebman. The number ends with a long fade and, for me, a touch prematurely: I should have liked to have heard a more expansive tune, something more emotive. ‘The Way I See It’ continues in a similar vein as the opening number with some nice trumpet work (player unidentified) and a good gentle rhythm from the percussionist. There is also a pleasant piano section, but I am aware that the word ‘nice’ (or any of its synonyms) is starting to become a repeated word.

‘Samba’ did at least lift the energy levels but coming in at a little over one minute this would not be for long and the added strings moderated any sense of vibrancy. ‘From Eddie P’ is a tribute to salsa great Eddie Palmieri featuring a 24-piece arrangement, and comes across well enough but lacks a certain level of authenticity until Victor Garcia adds his trumpet to the mix – and, thankfully it features quite heavily. Unfortunately, ‘Reconsider’ brings the listener back down from the Latin inspired high but only for a minute until ‘No Reruns’ takes over with the agreeable flugelhorn playing of Ron Parton. The piano section is also easy on the ear but it all sounds a little too pedestrian for my liking.

So, what of the album’s title track? ‘Shadow of a Soul’ is described as being “both lyrical and innovative. [Which is] what you would expect from a composer with a painter’s eye and an arranger steeped in classical harmonies.” I am sorry to say that I am unable to agree with that description and I think this piece highlights, for me, why I am unable to connect with this album: it is over arranged, there is no emotional correspondence for this listener to engage with and I was left unaffected by it. It is nicely written, nicely played but it lacks passion. However, there are another seven tracks to explore on Shadow of a Soul and you might find something there that will prove my thoughts to be a little harsh but, of course, they are only my opinion: subjective, not objective.

Musicians: Dave Liebman – soprano sax (track 1 & 8); Steve Duncan – trombone (track 4); David Bugher – vibes (track 4); Ron Parton – flugelhorn (track 7); Victor Garcia – trumpet (track 5); Ryan Cohan – piano (track 5).

Tracklist: 1. Mischievous Mark Colby. 2. The Way I See it. 3. Samba. 4. True Bloo. 5. For Eddie P. 6. Reconsider. 7. No Reruns. 8. Shadow Of A Soul. 9. Mu Hahn. 10. Fatal Honey. 11. Beeb’s Blues. 12. Only We. 13. Ambivalent. 14. Lushness For Life. 15. Yin and Yang.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.